Home/Podcast/Reading Made Us Both Cry

Episode 10 transcript Reading Made Us Both Cry

What if my child is not resisting reading, but is exhausted?

Claire reflects on mistaking reading fatigue for resistance and the moment she began asking what her son needed instead of pushing harder.

Direct answer

A short answer grounded in the transcript

Claire came to see that her son was not refusing reading itself; he was worn out by the way and moment she was asking him to do it. What looked like inconsistency was the effort of decoding taking more from him than she could see. Her question is whether a child’s resistance may point to a gap between our assumptions and how learning is actually working for them.

Dear Homeschool Mom: Grow Simply with Claire · October 6, 2026 · 3:20

Listen to the original episode

Listen on Spotify Apple Podcasts → Amazon Music → iHeartRadio →

Section 1

A reading practice that became a standoff

On the drive home from a field trip, Claire asked her son to read because he had managed a page from Magic Tree House a few days earlier. When he withdrew instead of reading, she pushed harder, certain that learning to read was not optional. In hindsight, she recognizes that insistence was not what he needed in that moment.

Section 2

What looked like forgetting was hard work

Claire had learned to read through patterns and constant reading, so her son’s inconsistent recall of blends did not make sense to her. She later understood that decoding was neurologically exhausting for him. The letter compares asking him to keep going to asking someone to drive on fumes.

Section 3

Looking beneath resistance

Claire does not conclude that reading was unimportant. She distinguishes the goal from the way she was pursuing it, and says she waited too long to make a call for help. Her closing question asks what may change when a parent becomes curious about the difference between how they expect learning to work and how it works for their child.

FAQ

Questions this episode helps answer

Why did Claire's son seem able to read one day but not another?

Claire says the work of decoding words was exhausting for him. What she first read as inconsistent recall or resistance may have been his concentration running out, rather than an absence of ability.

Does this episode say reading practice does not matter?

No. Claire calls reading an important skill. The letter questions the timing and pressure she used, and asks parents to consider what a child may need when the usual approach is not working.

From Claire

About the author of this letter

Written by Claire from grovio

Claire writes Dear Homeschool Mom for families who need reassurance, perspective, and a calmer way to trust the work they are already doing.

Try grovio

Keep track of what helps your child learn

Use grovio to capture the patterns, hard moments, and small wins you notice, so you have a clearer record of how your child learns.

Start with grovio free

Full transcript

Reading Made Us Both Cry

We were in the truck on the way home from a field trip, and I decided this was a good moment to practice reading.

He had read a page from Magic Tree House just fine a few days before. I had seen it with my own eyes. So I thought: let's keep the momentum going.

I asked him to read something.

He refused.

I pushed.

He went somewhere else entirely — not arguing, not fighting, just gone. That particular kind of gone where a child is physically present and emotionally unreachable. Eyes forward. Jaw set. Done.

And I kept going anyway. "You need to learn how to read. This is not optional. Every person needs to be able to do this."

True. Completely unhelpful. Not what he needed.

The more I pushed, the further he went. And the more frustrated I got, because I could not understand what was happening. He could read. I had watched him do it.

Why was it gone?

I had never been taught to read. Not systematically. I learned letter sounds, learned what digraphs made, and then at some point I just — read. Constantly, until speed and pattern recognition did the rest. And I thought that was how it worked.

So when his reading was inconsistent — when he would forget the sound a blend made five minutes after reading it correctly — I didn't know what I was looking at. My brain is built for pattern recognition. And here was my son, giving me no consistent pattern to recognize. I didn't understand it. And what I didn't understand, I pushed against.

What I was watching wasn't inconsistency for no reason. His brain was working hard in a way I couldn't see. The concentration required for him to decode words was exhausting — neurologically, specifically, really — and fatigue set in fast. What looked like forgetting was a tank running empty.

And I was in the driver's seat asking him to keep driving on fumes.

He wasn't resisting reading.

He was resisting the way I was doing it.

I kept pushing for another year before I finally made a phone call I should have made months earlier.

✦

A question I've been sitting with: What if the thing I was pushing against wasn't his resistance — what if it was the gap between how I thought learning worked and how it actually works for him?

Love,

Claire